The Broken Image: Man, Science, and Society by Floyd W. Matson. George Braziller. $6.95.
We are all rather tired of the Snow-Leavis controversy; partly, I think, because both sides score off their points without really earning them. Yeats, Pound, Wyndham Lewis, nine out of ten of those who have dominated literary sensibility in our time—weren’t they (asks Snow’s “distinguished scientist”) not only politically silly, but politically wicked? The question gets dismissed because it was accompanied by an analysis of the literary mentality as inevitably Luddite, blind to the prospects that labor-saving technology opens out to the poor, and by the round assertion of a general failure on the part of “the writers” to respond with full imaginative sympathy to the industrial revolution of the nineteenth century. The last point simply marks a failure of historical scholarship upon which Dr. Leavis was quick enough to pounce, the tradition of Ruskin, Arnold, and Morris being one of the fullest demonstrations of the humane awareness that social criticism derives from the literary imagination; while the charge of blindness lacks generosity, disallows the overstrenuousness that frequently accompanies the assertion of writers who confront a world hostile or indifferent to the claims of aesthetic experience. Both errors seem to originate in a disavowal of the meaning that Leavis puts upon the word culture. “Without thinking about it,” Snow writes of his scientists, “they respond alike. That is what a culture means.” For Leavis, however, culture means what William Morris had in mind when he wrote of certain reforms that “great as the gain would be, the ultimate good of it, the amount of progressive force that might be in such things would, I think, depend on how such reforms were done; in what spirit.” Culture means resistance to mechanism—not thoughtlessly responding alike, but refining the quality of response to the point of consciousness and self-determination.
