In Search Of Philosophic Understanding by E. A. Burtt. The New American Library, $5.75.
Professor Burtt’s new volume is in effect an extensive and often profound discussion of the genetic fallacy. He propounds, in psychoanalytic terms, the “functional” or pragmatic concept of mind: conceptualization is viewed as symbolic and instrumental, an expression of need, conflict, and motivation. Professor Burtt is profoundly concerned with what he calls “the relation between the cognitive adequacy of a basic presupposition and the motivating cause of its adoption… (for) that motive may influence the content of a presupposition as well as cause its adoption.” It seems to me that this distinction, if the functional hypothesis is to be taken seriously, is very tenuous indeed.
