Read the winning piece of our 2025 Nonfiction Contest “Through the Mirror” by Jessie Cato selected by Lucy Ives.

Read

Winter 1970 • Vol. XXXII No. 1 • The International Symposium on the Short Story, Part Four |

New Zealand

Who wants short stories? Who needs them? I ask as a Gissing man. That is, I edge into this symposium less as a New Zealander than as a writer who never really made it, neither kudos nor cash to show for a quarter of a century at the typewriter. There must be a lot of us! All the “promising” first novelists, the bright lads who soared to the “And Bear in Mind” panel, just below the best-seller list, of the New York Times Book Review (in my hour, anyway; maybe a Time listing is now the thing), waited for fame, waited—We belong here, don’t we? For most of us, remember, it began with a short-story, the short story.

I published my first when I was seventeen. It was called “Only a Kid of Course.” I published my last when I was thirty-nine (seven years ago). It was called “Other Gardens.” In between, 100 or so tales; in between, the making of a hack. (Gissing in 1897: “[Sidney] Lee told me of an oldish literary hack, who one day came to him in great discouragement, and said he should abandon literature. It turned out that he had been reading New Grub Street.”) I go at it like this, savaging it, because it’s the only way a Gissing man, the old bruiser grumbling in the dark, can hope to add anything to the discussion. He knows the definitions, he knows the names; a shrug for them all. What, all of them? Katherine Mansfield, too? Okay, I own up; I did say, in the obligatory piece for the New York Times when my first novel was published, that every young New Zealand writer works under the shadow of Mansfield’s greatness. But I was kidding—in a way. Certainly it’s irritating when distant reviewers drag her in nearly every time a piece of New Zealand fiction turns up. It’s an after-the-event irritation, though; nothing to do with why or how the story was written. No truly serious young writer, wherever he lives, is bothered by the shadows of his betters; he couldn’t write if he were. He knows the definitions, knows his Chekhov and his Maupassant, knows his Hemingway and his Faulkner, and so on. They, in his apprentice years, encourage him to keep trying for the true shape, the true mood—for the instants of revelation and delight that every good short story has. But he is not mindful of them, of his masters, as he writes; he is mindful of a glance, a remark, a biff—whatever it was that compelled him to write his story. If ever I look again at “Only a Kid of Course,” I dare say I’ll see the influences—maybe H. E. Bates, maybe Saroyan (Farrell came a little later). But I won’t bother to check, the title’s enough. It was a childhood story, something ironical (irony works so well in the short story). Another of my early stories, I recall, was “A Child’s Day.” We wrote a great deal about childhood in those years, during and just after World War II. Not only the young owns, either. Saroyan, Eudora Welty, Carson McCullers, Truman Capote, others. So innocence was meaningful then? We must have thought so. We must have stopped thinking so, perhaps by coincidence, about the time of the Salinger fever (around 1950?). Who now wants to read about childhood? Saroyan was fun. Now innocence is for clods. Which is tough on today’s young writers who, given a demand, would doubtless be in with their childhood stories.

Already have an account? Log in

Join KR for even more to read.

Sign up for a free account and read any five pieces a month.
Sign Up and Read for Free



Or become a subscriber today and get complete, immediate access to our digital archives at every subscription level.

Read More

England

By H. E. Bates

The history of the short story, both past and present, is beset with odd myths, some of them plain silly, and a considerable number of contradictions, some of them difficult […]

Subscribe

Your free registration with The Kenyon Review includes access to exclusive content, early access to program registration, and more.

Donate

With your support, we’ll continue 
to cultivate talent and publish extraordinary literature from diverse voices around the world.