New and Selected Poems by David Wagoner. Indiana University Press, $6.00.
David Wagoner seems to me one of our best poets, perhaps one of the best we have ever had in this country. I say “perhaps” because there is so much one might expect him still to explore, to attempt, that is as yet untouched in his verse, for Wagoner is a young man, his gifts are great, his commitment to craft exemplary. Which is to say, like any poet, Wagoner has his limitations, and, like the best poets, these limitations seem more a function of his strengths than a reflection of fundamental weaknesses in vision, feeling, or invention.
Wagoner is certainly not the sort of poet who ought to be popular with academic intellectuals, and in fact he seems to have caught on much more rapidly with his fellow poets than with the literary critics. For Wagoner’s verse presents few obstacles to the intelligence; one needs no special glossary to read his poems with pleasure, for they rest upon no mythologies, personal or traditional. Neither, at the same time, can Wagoner be expected to appeal to that vast audience of occasional readers to whom, say, Frost so appealed, for Wagoner’s poems do not flatter mundane notions of eccentricity, or take us on easeful joumeys into the interiors of the night. There is a brilliantly daring, erratic quality in Wagoner’s verse, a nearly explosive, impending presence that one feels only in very few of Frost’s poems. And the darkness, the silences in Wagoner are always drawing toward a nexus of fear and sensation, as in a dream the edges of which are always perfectly lucid, clearly defined, but which slip and give way to something in which they participate only partially.
To speak of the dream, though, in connection with Wagoner, may be to foster an altogether mistaken impression of his practice, for there is nothing merely or even largely fuzzy about his verse. The contours of his thought are unmistakable, and his concern for the hard spine of language is something one cannot miss. Nor, though one is tempted to do so, can one properly speak of the happy chance in Wagoner’s poetry, as one must in discussing Dr. Williams’ verse, for example. Associations in Wagoner are inventive, but hardly what one would call free, and the quality of dream is more a matter of weirdness, of vagueness of feeling, than of insufficiency in the various metaphoric equivalences, or of quirky disjunctions in argument. One thing Wagoner refuses to do is to conjure images as from the deep wellsprings of dream, and thereby to suggest identities, only to dismiss them all as meanderings of a diseased psyche, or as privileged metaphors such as may be identified with indulgent emotional states like the dream-trance of morbidly preoccupied individuals. Wagoner has his troubles staying alive—don’t we all—and he dreams a good deal about a control of his surroundings, and of his responses to it, that seems always to elude him, but Wagoner’s commitment to life, to the hard objects and choices of this world, is always more tenacious finally than the ambience of dream.
What one cannot but feel, coming away from Wagoner, is that whatever he touches, no matter how small, how minor, he alters, not in its dimensions so much as in the sheer quality and force of its presence. This holds true as well for objects as for human types and for tropes of language that had become so familiar we did not think they could any longer matter. Here is one of those poems, set in Wagoner’s glorious Pacific Northwest, that make us marvel. This man is a tightrope walker, we want to exclaim, an acrophobiac genius of dizzying heights, a man who can look down over the sheer edge of himself and laugh even as he clings for dear life. How maudlin, he seems to say, are life’s attempts to validate for us our own fears, the anxieties we generate out of our own gaping desert places and little persisting indifference:
OBSERVATIONS FROM THE OUTER EDGE
I pass the abrupt end of the woods, and stop.
I’m standing on a cliff as sheer as a step
Where the ground, like the ground floor of a nightmare,
Has slipped a notch six hundred rocky feet
And left itself in the lurch. My shoes go dead.
Not looking yet, I let my heart sneak back,
But feel like the fall-guy ending a Western,
The heavy, bound to topple from the edge
And disappear with terrible gravity.
I put my hand out in the separate air
With nothing under it, but it feels nothing.
This is no place for putting my foot down,
So I shout my name, but can’t scare up an echo.
No one inside this canyon wants to be me.
I manage to look down. Not much to envy:
The silent, immobile rapids, the toy pines,
A fisherman stuck in the shallows like an agate—
A world so far away, it could quit moving
And I wouldn’t know the difference. I’ve seen it before
At the ends of hallways, the far sides of windows,
Shrinking from sight. Down is no worse than across.
Whether it’s sky, horizon, or ground zero,
A piece of space will take whatever comes
From any direction-climbing, walking, or falling.
I remember a newsreel—a man holding a baby
Over the Grand Canyon on a stick:
The kid hung on and grinned for the camera.
I grab the nearest branch just to make sure
It isn’t death down there, looking like hell.
Even a mountain goat will go to pieces
Standing on glass suspended in the air,
But man created with a jerkier balance
Can learn to fix his eyes on a safe place.
Trembling somewhere,
The acrophobiac Primum Mobile
Clings to his starry axle, staring sideways.
