Integrities Pieces by Robert Creeley. Charles Scribner’s Sons, $4.50.
The Zigzag Walk by John Logan. E. P. Dutton and Company, $5.95.
Both Robert Creeley and John Logan live in a fallen world where self and other have been separated and where reuniting them becomes part of the poet’s task. Their newest volumes, Pieces and The Zigzag Walk, move significantly toward that reunification. But their methods of reunification are different both from each other and from the image of the shaman which so many contemporary poets have affected. Descended from a tradition of attacks on sloppy language like those which Ezra Pound launched in Homage to Sextus Propertius and “How To Read,” Creeley’s poetry approaches the accuracy demanded by John Ruskin of the ideal poet in Modern Painters: “The greatest thing a human soul ever does in the world is to see something and tell what it saw in a plain way. Hundreds of people can talk for one who can think, but thousands can think for one who can see. To see clearly is poetry, prophecy, and religion,—all in one.” Yet to see clearly requires an honesty that is not easily gained. It requires, as Creeley insists, not only a denial of simile (“always a displacement of what is happening”) but also a denial of the separate poem for poetry and prose, sequences, and a view similar to John Dewey’s “contexts of experience” or Alan Watts’s integrated man and world in “Wealth vs. Money”: “You say, ‘I came into this world.’ You didn’t; you came out of it, as a branch from a tree.” Most importantly, it requires an ability to react freshly to self in a society where from infancy photographs, recordings, films, mementos in bronze, and studies of personality indicate that prepackaged images of self are the culture’s biggest consumer product.
Creeley’s own statements of this honesty come in various forms. In the Preface to For Love, he writes of poems as a stumbling into places and of living “as we can, each day another” so that “there is no use in counting. Nor more, say, to live than what there is, to live.” He concludes by wanting the poem to be as close to this fact as he can bring it; or it, him. This closeness to fact, as he says in “Enough,” is always in these early poems a closeness to intention: “Make / a picture / for the world / to be. It / will be.” The “seeing” which Ruskin writes of thus is not of physical landscape but of mental states, emotional, temporal and physical relationships, loves, friendships, and amusements. Moreover, if the recurrent word in a Creeley poem is is, the recurrent tone becomes one of definition. By the fact of Creeley’s always stumbling from now into future, these definitions are saved from a dogmatism they might otherwise project. As Creeley describes the process in a Paris Review interview: “One time, again some years ago, Franz Kline was being questioned—not with hostility, but with intensity, by another friend—and finally he said, ‘Well, look, if I paint what you know, then that will simply bore you, the repetition from me to you. If I paint what I know, it will be boring to myself. Therefore I paint what I don’t know.’ ” Creeley goes on to add, “Well, I believe that. I write what I don’t know.” The closeness of this gained knowledge to truths of the moment rather than of all time permits for inconsistencies that put the knowledge finally closer to Kierkegaardian aesthetics than ethics.
In For Love and Words the stumbling was always a linear progress toward something. In Pieces, Creeley suggests that it can also be a way back: “A circling with / snake-tail in mouth— / what the head was / looked forward, / what backward is, / then guess. / Either way, /it will stay.” But, again, such looking back is different from “hindsight” or “horse’s ass,” as Creeley calls it. The realization of its phylogenetic, mythical cycle coeval with the earlier linear, ontogenetic world inspires the book’s two most exciting poems, “The Finger” and “Numbers.” The first Creeley admits is the result of a drug experience, but drug experiences have been part of his vision for a long time as “A Wicker Basket” and “Jack’s Blues” attest. They typify a way out of the closure which occurs in the mind of one who, in “The World,” senses the world’s encroaching pressure to accept its image of self and who consistently proposes that the world is an act of the imagination from which the imagination is then cut off. Explaining the impulse of “The Finger,” Creeley says, “I remember the business of this beautiful, primordial experience of woman, in the guise of my wife; but equally her image floating between the moments of birth—as girl-child to the most crone-like, the most haggish. Just crazily—all the guises of woman.” This experience which is both inner and outer contrasts markedly with his earlier image of woman in “The Wife.” Here one had two women, the one tangible substance and the other in his mind, and one manifestation had to die.It differs, too, from other manifestations of the White Goddess in For Love and Words where separate entity and physicality must be denied. “Numbers,” Creeley explains in the same Paris Review interview, is his only conscious attempt to set out “to write a poem literally about something.” It is a complement to Robert Indiana’s painting Numbers, and it again takes Creeley into that world of medium where “The words / are messages / from another, / not understood but given.”
None of these changes alters the matter of Creeley’s work, which continues to be a long monologue of self-definitions, sometimes extended to include other people, but kept away as much as possible from “the larger view” which makes him “very, very edgy.” On occasion, he uses the irony of the slushy, inexact, excessive, or bloated in language to escape self-definition as in “When holes taste good / we’ll put them in our bread” or “Better batter / bigger pancakes.” The absurdity of such marketplace language sets off the freshness and directness of his own diction, contributing to his tone a Catullus-like insouciance. Nor can his efforts completely avoid metaphor or simile. Repeatedly in his work he falls back on it, as love becomes “like going outside to see what kind of day it is,” truth, “like an apple reddened by frost and sun,” heaven and hell, “a form of corporate existence,” mind, “dark like the night,” and a face, “closed as a door—that insists on nothing.” Both the freshness of language and continually altering I-eye as “a locus of experience, not a presumption of expected value” offer the reader a near mesmerizing display of flexibility and variety.
