But, indeed, Ion, if you are correct in saying that by art and knowledge you are able to praise Homer, you do not deal fairly with me, and after all your professions of knowing many glorious things about Homer, and promises that you would exhibit them, you only deceive me, and so far from exhibiting the art of which you are a master, will not, even after my repeated entreaties, explain to me the nature of it. You literally assume as many forms as Proteus, twisting and turning up and down, until at last you slip away from me in the disguise of a general.
— Plato, Ion1
To command respect, the professional “reader” of literature has assumed a variety of guises, more or less disturbing to those of his contemporaries, like Socrates, who question his value and function. The Augustan arbiter of taste, the Arnoldian preserver of values, the New Critical pedagogue, has recently metamorphosed into a form that many, both inside and outside of academics, find particularly Gothic. “Suddenly, simultaneously, on many campuses and in many states,” writes Gore Vidal, “a terrible truth has become self-evident. ‘The true study of English studies is English studies.'”2 The beast born of that truth is the creative critic: the writer, to those who find the label oxymoronic, whose efforts are a violation of kind and who therefore deserves an unkind reception. The resulting confrontation, as described by Geoffrey Hartman in the New York Times Book Review, has been marked by melodramatic verbal violence:
