I’m writing this from the desert in Marfa, Texas, where I’ve spent a lot of time over the past four years. I wrote a poem here in 2008 called “The Resistance to Metaphor,” which could be a credo but isn’t. I resist metaphor but love metaphor; I resist it because I best understand the world as metaphor, and sometimes you need to resist your own tendencies. This week I heard the artist Robert Irwin (someone whose work means a lot to me) talk here about making art; he spoke about the necessity, above all, of being “available in response.” Meaning that if you set out to accomplish something particular in a piece, and the piece turns out to go in a different direction than anticipated, you need to be available in response to that changing thing. If moving to a new town turns out to be a different experience than you expected, you must be available in response. “Available in response” is not just a principle of craft; it’s a kind of spiritual credo.
I can’t resist metaphor successfully because for me poetry really is all about the space where metaphor is more “real” (in its denotative power) than conventional language might be. I think of poetry as the space where telling it slant is telling it straight: (“A certain slant of light …”). Wallace Stevens once wrote about “the hum of thoughts evaded in the mind,” a quote I love as a description of the lyric poem. When we write we are struggling to bring a thought or a sensation into being-in-language, to dredge it up from the ice or lava of the unconscious and into an alien form. Turning sensation into words—it is like making ice into air. The proceeding is (for me at least) intuitive and messy, like a blind person moving through a new space. I know it when it happens—when something about language and sentiment click into place and an uncanny violence and directness in the language brings forth beauty, or necessary estrangement, or just a casual clarity that nonetheless punctures the page. Some poems emerge slowly, like melting, and others erupt hot and must cool before you can work with them.
