If there were a competition for saints in which liberals could bid, George Orwell would be their man; he satisfies at once the liberal nostalgia for action and their resignation to despair. Simone Weil might be another choice. There is indeed a similarity between these two martyr figures, the frail intellectual Jewess sickening unto death in the Renault factory and the tired Etonian holding his own among the tramps; both made the futile gesture of going down among the “masses.” But Orwell remained a self-conscious representative of the cultivated, and his early books are defensive reports of his spiritual encounters in the depths of society; Simone Weil had a different intention. Her reports are not on the practical level of the novel or the memoir, and they have an oversubtlety that does not quite elude the ancient religious heresy she represents which finally makes her unacceptable not only to rationalist liberals but also to the conservative religiosi. Orwell remains the most adequate ideal. And in a liberalism that feels itself trapped by the Jewish question, he has the added advantage of not being Jewish. Moreover, Simone Weil, so far as she is relevant to secular questions, is no liberal. The Need for Roots serves, not altogether in agreement with her intention, the conservative polemic for a return to a traditionalist world, while the liberal mind prefers to live in more possible worlds. Simone Weil really looks beyond all present orders; one of Orwell’s attractions for liberals is his immersion in the here and now. He wrote to the question of how to live in the possible world, not how to die in an impossible one.
Honest living has always interested liberals more than holy dying: Orwell’s problem is how to live honestly in a world that is no longer liberal, and his unique perspective on the politics and poverty of the world was gained from being very honestly involved in both. Cyril Connolly had made the basic point about Orwell’s painful honesty in a biographical note on his old Eton friend in Enemies of Promise, and in this character Orwell has descended to us. “He was a virtuous man,” writes Lionel Trilling, in his introduction to the American edition of Homage to Catalonia; and this was, as Mr. Trilling calls it, his “moral triumph,” for Orwell’s personal virtue was practiced on the basis of a decisive confusion of principle. Orwell rose above his principles and this confers upon him his peculiarly modern saintliness. He is indeed worthy of our admiration, but the aura around his nobility and courage has left the darker side—his mind—relatively unexamined. For liberals, Orwell’s virtue as a man has obscured his significance as a writer. Thus Wyndham Lewis, of course not at all reverent, becomes in his recent The Writer and the Absolute the only critic who has treated Orwell at any length as a writer. His critical judgment, however unfair and perverse, nevertheless recognizes that Orwell is, of all “the English war and post-war writers, not alone the one most worthy of attention, but he is the only one.”
