Such, Such Were The Joys by George Orwell. Harcourt. $3.50.
One more posthumous volume of George Orwell’s essays is a new reminder that Orwell was always, equally, a social historian and an autobiographer. The social history is usually on the surface. It starts with the 19th Century, a time of poverty, hard work, and faith in the future. This faith began to be realized early in the 20th Century, but World War I put an end to progress. The precise moment of change may be different in different essays; it may be the Boer War or World War I—1910, 1914, or 1918. The “I” of Coming Up for Air has trouble distinguishing: “Before the war, and especially before the Boer War, it was summer all the year round.” In America, the highwater mark seems to have been reached just before the Civil War, but the point is always that things were better “before the war.” Following the 1920’s, “a period of irresponsibility,” the ‘thirties fostered poverty, which had now become meaningless because it was unnecessary; totalitarianism, which is unlike any of the older, gentler, Victorian or Edwardian forms of conservatism; and bully-worship, a product of totalitarianism and of the weak moral fibre of left-wing intellectuals. The future is just as certain a part of the historical pattern as the past, for the worst is yet to come: the spread of world totalitarianism, bringing with it the death of culture and freedom.
