Balzac is little read nowadays; he is remembered as one of the more unkempt geniuses of an unkempt century. As a psychologist he is not to be compared with his contemporary Stendhal, nor as a craftsman with his successor Flaubert. He is rather to be held up to the young as a monumental example of the consequences of indiscipline. The highest compliment likely to be paid him is that he was one of the first and most “strenuous” critics of bourgeois society. Karl Marx admitted to having learned much of his knowledge and his theory of that society from the Comédie Humaine. This is in a straight line with Brunetière’s judgment, in his famous Centenary Address at Tours in 1899, that Balzac would gain in value and importance with the passage of the years because his works were essentially “scientific documents.”
Yet an open minded rereading of Balzac can only leave us with the feeling that neither of these judgments does justice to the real quality and nature of his achievement. True, his psychological analysis lacks the concentrated brilliance of Stendhal at his best. But, then, it comes out of an incomparably broader grasp of the complexities of the situation. Balzac is continually trying to get more into the picture than Stendhal was capable even of imagining. (His own criticism of the author of Le Rouge et le Noir is that he was completely lacking in the moral sense.) And the same defense may be made in any comparison with his two immediate successors: his obsession with fact did not cause his emotions to seek relief either in the sulphurous pessimism of Flaubert on the one hand or in the blowsy optimism of Zola on the other. The view of life on which he operated was equally realistic with theirs; but it was a realism that had more in common with that of the Church than with that of 19th Century science. If we look at all closely into the view of life on which he was most of the time working we must decide that it was the tragic: the human will, taken either in the individual or in society as a whole, is the principle of evil. It is a force for destruction that it is the better part of wisdom to recognize from the beginning.
