Discussions about poetry incur a double danger. There is the danger of spoiling the poem under discussion by over-analysis, or by inopportune or inappropriate analysis; and there is the danger of losing sight of the poem in an effort to settle something about the poet’s life, about the philosophy espoused, about implicit sociological tendencies, or about clinical effects upon the reader. The first danger can be avoided only by the good sense and good taste of the critic. So long as he keeps his undistracted attention upon the poem itself the delicacy and depth of his appreciation will be the main determinants of critical success, and the achievement of these qualities is a matter of gradual, associative education.
The second danger, that of sliding imperceptibly from a discussion of the poem into a discussion of something with which the poem has historical or conceptual or functional connections, is more definite and therefore more remediable. While a good deal of such divagation can probably be explained by the critic’s obtuseness to, and consequent lack of interest in, the poetry of a poem, or by his attribution of this negative condition to his readers, or by his better familiarity with adjacent fields, or by his reasoned belief that serious interest in poetry is a contemporary anachronism, I suspect that a more direct obstacle to interpretative relevance in discussing a poem is semantic. We desire clarity, and our temptation therefore is to steer away from direct consideration of the poem, where clarity is incalculably difficult, into fields such as psychology, sociology, biography, ethics, or textual criticism, where clarity of a sort is already established. Of course the clarities found within these fields are not the clarities of poetry, they do not include the specific clarity that is sought in the appreciation of some particular poem; nevertheless they have the advantage of being utterable in a way that can be rather widely understood. They have achieved, in each case, their almost proper language.
