Yeats had as fine a personal endowment as a poet requires, and sometimes his successes were complete. Perhaps he was as great a lyric poet as our time permitted, and less than the greatest poets in the language only because of the special handicap under which modern poets must have labored. The last two centuries have been bad ones for the poets. I make the usual remark that we live in the age of science, but I will try to find a few words that will be a little more explicit than that.
Modern science is the only strict science. It seems fair to say that it has achieved its brilliant successes by means of resolutely simplifying its program, and limiting the act of free imagination that might otherwise muddle it. Science attacks its problem by defining its problems, and proceeding seriatim: divide et impera; one thing at a time; and, in every distinct operation, suppression of the ranging imagination. For modern science operates with images just as poetry does, or just as did old science, which was poetico-science. It handles the images harshly in order to focus them and make them manageable; regularly reducing them till they become bare patterns, or stereotypes, as clean and useful as they are void of the diffuse interest which is called aesthetic. So the brilliant successes came duly to crown the new technique, and that was splendid. But then, unduly, the successes over-impressed the poets, and seriously determined their practice too. We may be sure now that the scientific imagination and the poetic imagination are not of the same kind, and that the kinds of knowledge which they intend are not the same; and that it is just as impossible in the modern world for poetry to flourish in the practice of a pseudo-scientific imagination as it was impossible in the old world for a real science to arise unless it would repudiate the imaginative processes of poets. Yet that was the rôle which poetry assumed deliberately in the 18th Century, and continued, in spite of desperate efforts to find another one, in the 19th and early 20th Centuries. In all that period no poet has been more detached from the low standards prevailing in his art, better aware of its state of demoralization, than was Yeats. For fifty years he explored the possibilities of recovery.
