The Hero Who Can Prove It
I found the New York stage badly cluttered with ideas and problems this season. The distinction between what is dramatic and what is not is hard to draw, but it seems plain that none of the “serious” plays could have done without their melodramatic underpinning. To avoid confusion, I like melodrama, and I do not think that a playwright can do without ideas. Synge’s Playboy is a poetic play, and its preface contains one of the heartiest denunciations of the problem play ever written, but the playwright cannot have been unconscious of the idea that emerges from the play—the idea that Ireland has been swept bare of courage by oppression and is obsessed by a desire to take violent action against its oppressors. (This demand for violence is visible in any crowd gathered about an accident, and was expressed by the Cape Codder who told me after seeing an airplane crash that it was the only thing he had ever “really witnessed” in his fifty years.) Among such people the fear-driven Christy appears, and his fantasy of killing his father becomes the community’s myth. But Christy strikes his father a second time and destroys the myth by reducing it to the commonplace of brutality. The idea has been put to work, but it does not appear in the play—that is wholly given over to the characters who make and break the myth of heroism.
