[Editors’ Note: Mr. Leavis’ examination of Mr. Krutch’s recent book led him to make a fresh statement of Johnson’s whole achievement. The sub-title is ours.]
Mr. Krutch’s book,1 I must confess, surprised me very agreeably. It is not only inoffensive; it is positively good. I had better add at once that I write in England and as an English-man. In this country, to those seriously interested in literature, the cult of Johnson is an exasperation and a challenge. It is a branch of goodmixing, and its essential raison-d’être is anti-highbrow: it is to further the middlebrow’s game of insinuating the values of goodmixing into realms where they have no place—except as a fifth-column, doing their hostile work from within. Johnson, one finds oneself having again and again to insist, was not only the Great Clubman; he was a great writer and a great highbrow—or would have been, if the word, and the conditions that have produced it, had existed; that is, he assumed a serious interest in things of the mind, and, for all his appeal to “the common reader,” was constantly engaged in the business of bringing home to his public and his associates, whose cult of him was a tribute to the force with which he did it, that there were standards in these things above the ordinary level of the ordinary man. But when the University of Oxford conferred a doctorate honoris causa on P. G. Wodehouse, it was exemplifying the ethics of our modem Johnson dub. And there is too good reason for expecting that a new book on Johnson by one of the academic custodians of the “humanities” will exhibit the kind of literary accomplishment that goes with an admiration for the prose of (say) Miss Dorothy Sayers, the brilliance of Mr. C. S. Lewis, and the art of Lytton Strachey.
