The great success of the 1925 Moscow film season was not Potemkin, but some undistinguished Hollywood colossus; some thirty-five years later, Eisenstein had his season in New York. His huge presence looms even larger now than then; somehow, the twilight casts a more enhancing shadow than the dawn. The Museum of Modern Art Film Library is perforce becoming a mausoleum. Where will one today find a work so vast, so ambitious, as to challenge the pre-eminence of the early classics? Is it only twilight that descends, or some more permanent darkness?
Which is, perhaps, a somewhat elaborate way of saying that things are not so good, and, perhaps, suggesting that they were not ever so good as it may now seem. The Museum of Modern Art’s retrospective Eisenstein exhibition struck me as being as significant of our past excesses as of our present dearth. We still do not really know what has been genuinely important in the brief, tragical history of the film; at least, we seem incapable of discriminating it from the flamboyance of mere specious success. It is not the forest that the trees obscure; rather, the other trees, those closer to the center. The presence looms large; with the Soviet Union’s release of Ivan the Terrible, Part II, for cultural export, the recent rediscovery of Stitke, his first and previously almost forgotten film, and the present availability of his writings, Eisenstein stands before us whole. The figure imposes upon our imagination. demanding judgment. There once was a man named Sergei Eisenstein, and, somehow, we must attempt to come to terms with him.
