Read the winning piece of our 2025 Nonfiction Contest “Through the Mirror” by Jessie Cato selected by Lucy Ives.

Read

Spring 1962 • Vol. XXIV No. 2 • Department KR: A Section of Briefer Comment |

Two Movies and Their Critics

There is not really much similarity between La Dolce Vita and L’Avventura. Both were made at about the same time, and in the same country; if anything, they only show how big, artistically, one country can be. But the films have, in fact, been brought together by a rather arbitrary event: the publishing of twin encomia to them in the pages of the Autumn issue of The Hudson Review. In his analysis of the Fellini film, Norman N. Holland makes mention of Time magazine, which, “following its current mythy bent,” argues that La Dolce Vita is, in fact, a monumental allegory of the book of Revelation and the Second Coming. Well, as they used to say around my block, it takes one to know one. Holland pursues the Time suggestion to its most detailed and elaborate and doctrinaire extremes; no doubt, he rates a cover. No names are “without significance,” which is true enough; that is the function of names: they signify. When Anita Ekberg is offered a huge pizza, she is “ritually… offered the fruits of the Roman fields.” In the sequence in which Marcello, the film’s non-hero, is visited by his father, a night club suggests to Holland a place where “the walls glitter like a temple’s and everywhere there are statues of women.” But is not a night club precisely a place where the walls glitter and everywhere there are women? Please don’t ask. For we are in the presence of Myth.

Why pick on Norman Holland, certainly not the greatest offender when it comes to the abuse of film criticism? And, certainly, as both Parker Tyler and Mlanny Farber have many times showed us, there are many ways of not writing film criticism while allegedly writing film criticism. Now between the relentless myth hunting of The Hudson Review and the dogged popular culturism of Commentary, I will take the latter, for, while both approaches seem to me fundamentally antithetical and even hostile to art, the latter, at least, allows implicitly of the possibility of some supplementary, if not alternative, way of getting at the subject. I have nothing against the elucidation of myth per se. Indeed, I thought the original intent of such a method was to reveal how the individual work of art transforms the myth, how it adapts and uses it for its own particular ends. Instead, we are now treated to a painstaking annotation of a work’s mythic elements, and then… but that is all—the end! The elements are articulated (often impressively; I, for one, am impressed by Holland’s learning, if not his accomplishment), and the case rests proven, Q.E.D.; but the commentator has, in fact, proven—what? That the presence of myth is one with the presence of art; that the presence of myth is art’s chief fulfillment? The comments of Time have, at least, the power of suggestion. Tentatively, they open the discussion; dogmatically, Holland closes it. Here, one last time, is the voice of the critic speaking. “Man is impotent, helpless, Marcello’s dying father or Steiner, with his sounds and language, frozen, turned into stone by the fixity of his life. (Indeed, sacred to Cybele was a small meteoric stone acus, supposed to have fallen from the heavens.)” Q.E.D.

Already have an account? Log in

Join KR for even more to read.

Sign up for a free account and read any five pieces a month.
Sign Up and Read for Free



Or become a subscriber today and get complete, immediate access to our digital archives at every subscription level.

Read More

Subscribe

Your free registration with The Kenyon Review includes access to exclusive content, early access to program registration, and more.

Donate

With your support, we’ll continue 
to cultivate talent and publish extraordinary literature from diverse voices around the world.