To submit an adverse opinion on Mr. Anderson’s war play involves a very heavy responsibility. And yet it is a responsibility that must be faced. In Marxist terms, the fashionable terms of adverse criticism in the recent past, this would be a simple enough job. But unfortunately the writer is not a Marxist. And this point is made at the very outset because it is very important, in this context and once and for all, to distinguish between a point of view, in the sense that it will here be used, and a merely Marxist point of view.
It is my opinion that what is wrong with The Eve of St. Mark is its lack of a point of view. I propose to make this specific, but at the same time to refer briefly to certain other work of Mr. Anderson’s that may clarify what I mean. In general, I think Mr. Anderson’s constant reaching for art has landed him, despite the superficial topicality of much of his recent work, not merely in a social, but also in a moral, vacuum.
