F. O. Matthiessen has undertaken to give in twenty-two pages a cross-section of the rather large body of the poetry of Herman Melville.1 If he had intended to give merely a little gathering of his poet’s best blossoms, his task would have been relatively easy. But he has also undertaken, as he says in his brief but instructive preface, to “take advantage of all the various interests attaching to any part of Melville’s work.” So some items appear because they present the basic symbols which are found in the prose or because they “serve to light up facets of Melville’s mind as it developed in the years after his great creative period.”
In one sense all one can do is to say that Mr. Matthiessen, with the space permitted by the series to which this book belongs (“The Poets of the Year”), has carried out his plan with the taste and discernment which could have been predicted by any reader of his discussion of Melville’s poetry in the American Renaissance. But I shall take this occasion to offer a few remarks supplementary to the preface and to point out other poems and passages in Melville’s work which I hope Mr. Matthiessen admires or finds interesting but which could have no place in his arbitrarily limited collection.
