Read the winning piece of our 2025 Nonfiction Contest “Through the Mirror” by Jessie Cato selected by Lucy Ives.

Read

Spring 1946 • Vol. VIII No. 2 • Book Reviews |

Some Culled Fictions

Trial Balance: The Collected Short Stories of William March. Harcourt, Brace. $3.50.

Mother And Son by Clarkson Crane. Harcourt, Brace, $2.50.

 … And The Field Is The World by Dola Delong. Scribner. $2.50.

Seven Times The Leading Man by Egon Hostovsky. L. B. Fischer. $2.75.

The Dwarf by Pär Lagerkvist. L. B. Fischer. $2.50.

I am too greatly under the spell of William March to tag him for posterity. But on my shelves at least he has by-passed the big avant-garde experimental names at the top and gone straight to the bottom—near Ring Lardner, a newly dusted Saki and some older, more furtive treasures. Speaking with all relative caution, one does not expect these days to find so much pleasure from a book. With Goethes and Rilkes everywhere, here is a small writer minding his formal business and letting the big throbbing heart of life mind its own. True, the big ideas are here, packed elaborately in tiny anecdotal satires; and the symbols do expand like paper flowers. But this modest and witty perfection causes many climaxes to burst with blooded authority from their forms.

Beginning in 1928 with a decently skeptical Marx-Freud synthesis, the stories are by ’44 more subjective, melancholy, comic—smaller and truer in every way, I think—having meanwhile dramatized nearly every leading idea of our time. A topical interest, to say the least! But first many lives and quiet desperations. The discrepancy between dream and actuality, caught at the moment of despair or greatest honesty: death, psychosis, failure. The dying woman who wanted to train pigs in a circus, her life “thrown away.” And the husband, ironically: “She made me a good wife. … We had a sweet full life together.” And the Static Sisters (’44) in whom the insight struggles, (almost psychoanalytically), that they have become Siamese blooms on a faded Southern tree because singly each would be destroyed. But the motivation is unFreudian—historical rather than hysterical, you might say. Then the three charwomen in a pub, making reminiscence fugally on ancient glory: they know the truth but are hardened to it. And in the most beautiful and compassionate of all (’43) a widow learns that her husband is really dead, that she is old, and that her Willow Fields— are death.

Other dreamers escape the truth—but we learn it—through their less conscious perversions and deliriums. Even murder. A Shoe Drummer kills an elderly—whore? sweetheart? scorned mistress-for-the-night? What a language!—Anyhow, he murders the poor woman for the crime of sleeping with him, when he might so easily have killed his whorish mother instead. And this story, incidentally, is another technical marvel: a psychosis, with its lifetime motivation, done completely in Lardner-style dialogue and semi-literate introspection, with no narration at all. Then many dreams insanely realized:—Sex (a lady becomes a Wood Nymph); Love (the thrice-unmarried heiress becomes a grey-haired child); Hatred (the crippled Sunday School Teacher is a sadist, the Noble Executive a shoe fetishist, etc.); Greed (the avaricious become tomb-worshippers, or worse); Religion (the preacher exorcises a moron and kills the swine). But particularly Justice. Though all true reformers end in asylums, jails, or in conformity, March has developed some wonderfully moving techniques for making justice human before it conforms or loses its mind.

Already have an account? Log in

Join KR for even more to read.

Sign up for a free account and read any five pieces a month.
Sign Up and Read for Free



Or become a subscriber today and get complete, immediate access to our digital archives at every subscription level.

Read More

Subscribe

Your free registration with The Kenyon Review includes access to exclusive content, early access to program registration, and more.

Donate

With your support, we’ll continue 
to cultivate talent and publish extraordinary literature from diverse voices around the world.