Clurman and his Group Theatre had to fail ultimately, because the task was, as he foresaw, an impossible one. What he and the Group aimed at was the unattainable: a permanent theatre of their own with a permanent stock of actors, working constancy and planfully, as a creative and truly representative American theatre, the free “association of the strongest creative forces of the country,” the concentration and accumulation of contemporary talent in all the branches, writing as well as acting and directing. The group dissolved after ten years; its thirty or so members diverged into different directions, taking shelter in Hollywood and on Broadway.
What the Group aimed at did not and does not exist: in its full realization, this would be a National Theatre, founded on the true principles of art, methodically developed and organically growing, not subjected to the whims of buyers and backers, inspiring its artists, writers, actors and technicians, educating the audience and—if possible—the critics. Of such an institutional American theatre there exist only blue prints and advisory commissions. It should necessarily be sustained either by a vast organization of audiences or by the government, by states or cities; or by workers’ unions, as a theatre of the people. Models of this kind of theatrical institution can be seen at work in Europe, especially in Russia and in Germany.
Clurman proves again and again why this kind of theatre goes “against the American grain.” He describes and discusses the Broadway system and practice, its competitive character, its gamble, its waste and diffusion, its lack of tradition, of continuity and organized craftsmanship. He does it often with a caustic objectivity. He cannot always avoid preaching. He cannot conceal his passion, the nearly religious fervor of an old fighter and sectarian, but is at his best when he chooses the form of understatement. After all, the stage is not the salvation army, and a reformer, a lawgiver of the theatre, must remain a man of the world.
Nevertheless Clurman’s personality as revealed in his book appears unlike the generally accepted type of the showman, who has to play the roles of an entrepreneur and of a master of ceremonies, with traits of a Cagliostro. The last showman of worldwide fame and great stature was Max Reinhardt, at the boom of an era of plenty, rehabilitating old traditions and bringing them to a new climax. Reinhardt, and even Stanislavsky, distilled the essence of an established society. Stanislavsky worked in the Russian way, in collectives; after the revolution, he became the innovator of a new beginning, the benefactor of till then untouched strata of audiences. Reinhardt envied him these audiences, when his own bourgeois society began to crumble.
Clurman lacks the aura which surrounded those masters, as unlike each other as they were. And his treatise lacks the phosphorescence and splendor usually given to books dealing with the theatre. His record resembles in places a sober sociological analysis. But it contains the biographical sketches of a dozen artists, in particular a loving but discerning portrait of the outstanding dramatist of the epoch, Clifford Odets—plus all kinds of valuable criticism.
The story of the “Group,” if only by negation, sheds light on its competitors, the “Theatre Guild” and some independent minor theatrical groups with political intentions. Broadway’s commercial amusement park, the not entirely legitimate stage, serves as the heavy of the piece. In spite of all the analytical discourses, the book tells an adventure story, Clurman being the leading character and the “Group” his materialized ego, and vice versa. It presents itself as the record of a failure, and as the apology for this special kind of failure. But at the end, the reader is not certain whether it is not a success story.
The Group exists no more. Did it leave any traces? Did the Group produce a distinguishable dramatic form? A style, even a fragmentary one (like “Epic Theatre”)? Or is its most memorable deed its struggle for building a theatrical collective, and keeping it together, making it work against odds?
It was serious, and inspired some work on a very respectable level. The Group was distinguished by a methodical approach, the so-called Stanislavsky method. It belongs undoubtedly to the merits of the Group to have proved the practical value of this special kind of teaching and training; their best performances have given the most representative example of the success and, on the other hand, the limitations of this method. Did the Group inaugurate, at least in this respect, a tradition?
The most gifted members of the Group continue to work as actors and directors on Broadway and in Hollywood. They have to prove, by their individual work, what they have learned in the Group. Are they carrying on the practices developed during the decennium of their collective existence? There is no question that they had to adapt their method to the conditions of Broadway where no seventeen weeks are allowed for the rehearsing of a play; neither is the seclusion possible which would guarantee methodical and concentrated work. Can the method be used at all, under the rushing demands of the entertainment factory?
Apologists of the Group answer these questions in the affirmative. The Group has not developed what one would call a great actor, but quite a few competent and some very fine actors. It is remarkable how largely its members took to directing and teaching. Many directors of distinction have come out of the Group: Lee Strasberg and Clurman, and their after-growth, Sanford Meisner, Robert Lewis, Elia Kasan. All of them—even an actress of such an emotional sweep as Stella Adler—have become teachers as well. In both capacities they uphold the tradition of the Group and convey their knowledge and experience to the next generation.
Neither aesthetically nor politically did Curman have any definite intentions. He was neither a playwright nor really an actor. We find him in the early ‘twenties, a drifting young intellectual, an American student in Paris, interested in art but not exclusively in the theatre, even if he concluded his studies at the Sorbonne with a thesis on the French Drama from 1890 to 1914. (His research work must have made him familiar with the origin and development of Naturalism.) This seemed to point dearly enough to critical analysis as his personal calling. When he returned to America, he had to look for a job: “ … with the background I have just described, there seemed little choice but for me to seek it in literary and theatrical fields.” “The writing world, in my view, had more dignity; the theatre was somehow more available.” The ‘twenties reflected in their entertainment the boom after the War. ‘The answer to everything was money, the guarantee that everything was as it should be was pleasure.” The slogan: “Invest in your country, it can’t go wrong,” found its representative theatrical expression in the Guild, a theatre on a cultural level, based on an audience organization.
It is Clurman, the beginner, the bit-player and the reader of the Guild, who enjoyed when amidst actors “the human vibration of the people in their common play and enthusiasm,” and who found in the theatre “the flower of large social contact, even when the occasion for this contact, in terms of literature, was a silly anecdote.” His “flesh had a natural hankering for the atmosphere of the theatre”; but he exclaims, “I clamored for greater occasions, for closer embrace, for a more rooted togetherness.” It sounds in the retrospect rather pathetic when he draws his ultimate conclusion of twenty years ago: “I can’t live without the theatre, but I can’t live with it.” Still, this is the typical experience of a man who wants more from the theatre than “du théâtre.”
At the same time there existed people whose aesthetic opinions were less “occasionally conscious” than Clurman’s. There were, besides the Guild, the Provincetown Players and the Greenwich Village Theatre. In the American Laboratory Theatre Boleslavsky and Ouspenskaya taught the Stanislavsky method for the first time to American students; one of their most promising adepts being Lee Strasberg, a fanatic who “argued with astonishing heat and pedagogic finesse,” whom Clurman was soon to meet. This young actor proved to be the shoot planted for the propagation of a foreign theatrical culture. What followed now between Strasberg and Clurman, and a growing group of young people who began to congregate, was talk, talk and some more talk. Clurman especially must have been always a great talker, with the indination to be a preacher. But there was something else in his makeup, an unusual ability to analyze and interpret other people’s work and personality. He could have become a critic of authority, but his deepest urge forced him to be a doer. Not only did he understand “that the so-called interpretative elements were really creative functions,” but, what was even more important, that a body, a collective, had to be created through which to make the ideas work. Whoever suggested, Clurman or Strasberg, Meisner, or Cheryl Crawford, the most practical of them, that “a special kind of organization was necessary,” and that for this purpose the then-gathered little company had to be set up in a country place for the summer, where they could rehearse, that person made the most important step toward the founding of the Group. As Clurman expresses it: “From the experiment in the theatre we were in some way impelled to an experiment in living.”
The adventures of the Group make the most original and instructive parts of the book, but they should be read in their lively context. I suppose Clurman worked out his report of this development over years by following notes taken while the process was going on. No anecdote is without a meaning, every instance becomes a symptom for the experiment in living as well as for the experiment in the theatre. The result is a continuity, full of suspense and dramatic values; a story pregnant with human strife and human experience. So many people are involved, I cannot repeat the roll call of them, who grew through the Group in making the Group grow, and of the others, who got lost and became the victims of the Group. Clurman himself gives only a selection of names which, as he thinks, are still in the mind of the public; quite a few of his helpers have to remain anonymous, people of the technical staff for example. He cannot dwell as much as he perhaps wants to on personal credits. But he seems to follow step by step the life of the Group: growing illnesses and accomplishments; narrow impasses and steady widening of the horizon. He accentuates several summers of collective life and work as different stages on the way to perfection. There are many influences from the outside: guests, patrons, backers and dilettantes. There are the protagonists within the group, and their often embittered competition; the struggle between the mass and the leaders. Centrifugal forces and integrating ones, personified in youngsters of both sexes; egotism and self sacrifice, individual ambition and the voluntary subordination under the common aim. Such records can be given of every well intentioned group. But one must not forget: they are actors! This group of players, repeatedly without money and without a play; patronized at first—but not sufficiently—by the powerful Guild; often on the breaking point and as often reassembling; with failures that were successes and successes that were temptations; encouraged without full recognition and subdued when they needed encouragement most; balancing between depression and high headedness; and again and again emerging from bleak despair with empty stomachs but with new confidence: what a touching contemporary drama was enacted in this struggle of the Group for bare living and qualified work!
An American drama. All the players American. Clurman insists on the importance of this fact. Whatever the foreign influences and impulses which the Group received, they were used only for the expression of American life. The Group produced, with no exception, American authors only: Paul Green, Maxwell Anderson, T. H. Lawson, Dawn Powell, Sidney Kingsley, Clifford Odets, Irwin Shaw, Saroyan, and others. Some of the actors were Phil Loeb, Stella Adler, Franchot Tone, Luther Adler, Morris Carnovsky, Art Smith, Lee Cobb, Sanford Meisner, Russell Collins, John Garfield, J. E. Bromberg, Roman Bohnen, Alexander Kirkland—all from American stock. The influence of scenic artists, closely related to the group, like Mordecai Gorelik, Boris Aronson, and others, must not be forgotten; nobody worked exclusively in his special field. There was never a star or a guest player called in from outside; there was no ancient or modern classic performed, no “revival.” The members of the Group, sons and daughters of their country and their period, brought with them their conditioning, their milieu and their affinity for the social climate, the problems and the ideologies of the years between the depression and the outbreak of the second World War.
The Group taught its leaders. Clurman admits: “The facts of our society, however, came to me accidentally”; he means, “through our work.” “The crash of 1929 had made no impression on me.” But the rehearsals and the performance of Claire and Paul Sifton’s play in 1931, dramatizing unemployment, impressed him. So did the effect of the play: the new audiences it attracted. He wonders, at first, about the “sudden preoccupation with social, economic and political matters,” which he observes all around him. He is utterly absorbed in the theatrical life of the Group, and only through the Group he acquires his “sense of the theatre in relation to society”—and, I may add, to reality. Out of the rank and file of the Group, when he began as an unimportant young actor, grows Clifford Odets, the representative playwright of the Group and of the ‘thirties. Clurman did not recognize his talent too soon: Waiting for Lefty had to be produced first, 1935, at the Civic Repertory Theatre, under the direction of Sanford Meisner and Clifford Odets. But he was Clifford’s friend, his confidant, his critic, and ultimately his best interpreter. In this function, Clurman becomes a creative director himself and completes, what Lee Strasberg began and developed through the first years, the integrated realistic style of the Group.
This full grown style can be studied by people who have not seen the performances, in Odets’ plays from Awake and Sing to Paradise Lost. It is—Clurman assures us again and again—an autochthonous American style. Clurman defends Odets against the insinuation of being influenced by Anton Tchekov. Odets knew nothing or little of Tchekov when he began writing his own stuff. Well, even if Odets had read no Tchekov play at this time, he may have heard enough about the Russian to learn something from him. Such influences are infectious through the air. The identity of Tchekov’s dramatic form with the form of Odets’ middle class family plays cannot be denied, the deep relationship is obvious and self-evident, as a tradition is in divergent variations. Clurman stresses—rightly so—the differences in temperament and tempo. I can well recognize the specific accumulations of Odets’ situations, their inner drive to vehement reactions and outbreaks (which are not absent in Tchekov); charged, as they were, not only with a different degree, but with a different kind of electrical current. The typical Tchekov play, too, is “a protest that is also a prophecy”; it is, of course, softlier harmonized, the minor prevails over the major key; and the melody is entirely different To be a Russian realist before the first World War and the Revolution, or this American realist between the two World Wars: a different milieu and a different task. The nostalgic element in Tchekov becomes violent irritation with Odets: a fever curve. Frustration seems more beyond hope. Odets’ lyricism mounts more boldly, in a higher angle, from triviality to poetry, without ever giving up its idiomatic roots; admirable short-cuts; many a Rocket to the Moon from the gutter of the human heart. Odets’ last acts, especially in his plays after Awake and Sing, waver between the coma of defeat and hope against hope. They sometimes don’t know how to make a full stop. They go on preaching after the play is over. Should it be that this American period could not guess its last act?
