No one was more frequently banished from the court of Charles II than the Earl of Rochester. This was generally a consequence of his private life, and of that we know perhaps too much. Dr. Johnson wrote of the man who “lived worthless and useless” until he had “exhausted the fund of life”—that is in itself a complete biography. Rochester arrived at a court notorious for its freedoms and even there he became legendary. He wrote of and perhaps experienced most of the sexual aberrations. He exposed himself literally and others metaphorically, describing with appalling honesty the sexual mores of a seventeenth-century court. Much of the legend was true: he employed spies in the apartments of Whitehall, and kept a running book on what was being done to whom. The poems that resulted were more feared than sermons. He was involved in beatings, orgies, deceptions, assaults, and manslaughter. Rochester was in fact a great outrager of public order; his biography has always served what one hopes are exemplary purposes. But it is another biography that should engage us, and that is the life of his work. It is not always useful to separate the children of light from the children of darkness; Rochester, like Rimbaud, De Sade, and Baudelaire, was a certain kind of moralist.
It is probably best to begin with some traditional estimates of Rochester. Edmund Gosse typifies those who end the case in terms of moral criminality. For him, Rochester was simply a “plague spot in English literature and English society.” This was a truth of a certain kind, but it could not be used to establish further truths. Taine was equally hostile, but rather more intelligent. His criticism of Rochester was like his famous attack on Swift: he saw monstrosity in the writings and invented a monster as the author. Yet he was left with the knowledge of a certain disparity: this sensual maniac had “studiously and deliberately” addressed himself to his course of life and art. The worst that could be said of him was that “he writes without spirit, and methodically enough. He has no natural ardour, no picturesque sensuality. … Nothing is more disgusting than obscenity in cold blood.” Nothing, on the other hand, is more revealing. The sensibility Rochester was to create could only be understood in terms of “cold blood,” for it was a sensibility of failure.
