What Is American In American Art, edited by Jean Lipman. McGraw-Hill Book Company. $12.50.
This is a collection of essays gathered from the first 50 years of Art in America, and the topics covered range from painting to furniture, from gravestone ornamentations to playing cards, postage stamps, photography, and jazz. It is very much a sampler, despite its declared attempt to “define in a new way the distinctly national flavor of our art.” Even as a sampler, however, it exhibits some curious imbalances: there are four excellent “portfolios,” largely in color, of New England gravestone rubbings, primitive watercolors, Andrew Wyeth’s work, and lithographs by contemporary artists—but the emphasis is thus on early and current art. Without wishing any of these portfolios omitted, one would have liked to see others representing especially important periods and values. And if postage stamps and playing cards and jazz are to come under discussion, why not the whole field of industrial design, or other forms of music which seem peculiarly American?
