After the Death of Poetry: Poet and Audience in Contemporary America by Vernon Shetley. Durham: Duke University Press, 1993. xii, 209 pages. $39.95, $13.95 paper.
Many critics have decided that poetry is dying, dead, or in decay, and their engraver is poised to chisel a tombstone date-of-death somewhere between 1945 and 2001. It is probably too easy to assign the fatal cause as deriving from the general malaise of apocalypse because of the fin de siècle of two millennia, though that may seem a contributing factor. Just consider the titles of a few other recent books about poetry: Jonathan Holden’s The Fate of American Poetry; Karen Mills-Courts’s Poetry as Epitaph; Dana Gioia’s Can Poetry Matter?; Timothy Steele’s Missing Measures; Wyatt Prunty’s ‘Fallen from the Symboled World‘. To say nothing, of course, of Joseph Epstein’s notorious Commentary article “Who Killed Poetry?” All of these except Mills-Courts speak to a decline in poetry’s readership, its slender cultural relevance, and to a schizophrenia of formal attitudes, yet each describes a different scenario for blame and praise. Vernon Shetley’s fine After the Death of Poetry argues with the view that poetry’s day is done, though he finds it imperiled. I appreciate this passionate, clearly presented book, even when I ultimately disagree with some of his opinions of the important poets or their praiseworthy manners. Shetley tries to frame reasons and methods by which to breathe life back, not only into poetry, but more so into our readerly imaginations, into our need to savor and sustain those mysteries of feeling which poetry best creates and celebrates. Speculative criticism can articulate “the corrosive doubt about the nature of subjectivity … that thinking people now inhabit,” Shetley contends; “but only poetry can tell us how living with and in that doubt affects the nature of our feelings” (29). The more rational critics hate mystery and feeling.
