By way of introducing these remarks on the value of In Our Time I want to make a broad and somewhat crude observation which I hope will fix the reader’s attention on my present focus of interest. I think of Hemingway as the writer to whom everything happens. And fortunately for us he has had sufficient skill to write up the stories of the people to whom everything happens. He is genially candid on this point: “I would like to live long enough to write three more novels and twenty-five more stories. I know some pretty good ones.” Now if this is a fair view of Hemingway, it might be no less fair to compare him in this respect to Henry James. Hemingway is the writer everything happens to and should therefore end up as a non-writer, except that he has a complex sense of duty. (“Now it is necessary to get to the grindstone again.”) And vulgarly speaking, Henry James is the man to whom nothing ever happens. Things could be worse for a writer. (One recalls James’s peevishness at having his sacred mornings for work interrupted by high-minded ladies in New York.) I suggest there is a broad rift in the possibilities of fiction today and that Hemingway and James are representative of the factions. James extended magnificently the possibilities of fiction in the direction of poetic drama, ignoring the kind of social, economic, and historic verisimilitude that Edmund Wilson requires from fiction; Hemingway, with his journalistic training, his wide and not shallow experience, and his gift for colloquial language, rendered for his contemporaries the life of their own times. Put more philosophically, the distinction is this: It takes more of an act of will to put pictorial effect into a novel (and to receive it) than to put it on the stage—it’s there already. Hence the novelist and the playwright are two different varieties of Nietzsche’s Augenmensch—the playwright has more of the Ohrenmensch in him. James put his poetic dramas into the form of novels and sacrificed thereby much of the moral persuasive force possible in prose narrative; Hemingway, as purer, appetitive Augenmensch, writes moral tracts for our times. I may be dead wrong, but I feel, the world being what it is nowadays, that the novelist needs more of the Augenmensch in him and less of the Ohrenmensch.
In Our Time has its share of crudities, which would no doubt disgust a sensibility nurtured on James. But consider the harassed sensibility of the man who, within a week, reads or rereads in sequence In Our Time, The Ambassadors, Antony and Cleopatra, and Lycidas. Would he finish each work with a measured sense of disgust at the limitations of its predecessor? He should not, of course: he should reflect, Here are four reputable craftsmen working in different mediums and unto different ends—the ends seem legitimate.
