Although Henry Green has been writing for twenty-five years and has been famous for at least ten, no one writes articles on him. This could be an estimate by silence, but I suspect it is more a symptom of modern embarrassment in writing about comedy. Comedy still seems only comedy and, besides, there is a painful discrepancy of tone between it and criticism. Its author is witty, personal, symbolic, specific. The critic looking for direction in several novels is necessarily more abstract, often impersonal, seldom witty. He may find himself trying to explain the how of comedy. At best, if he admits the limitations of his medium, he can say a little about the how and a little more about the where of the comedy in a few novels.
Most readers of Green like him for extraordinarily funny scenes like Edie’s telling Kate she has found the Captain in Mrs. Jack’s bed, or old Rock angrily waiting for his breakfast handout in the girls’ school kitchen. But readers to whom I have talked finish Loving or Concluding, as I did, unsure of what else happened. There is something to be said for leaving the situation at that. Scenes are obviously Green’s natural units and it is easy to suspect that, if the general direction were only a little clearer, we might not like it anyway. Still, the effort to say more accurately what we have read in a contemporary tells us something not only about him and ourselves, but also something of what we really think—or suspect—about his predecessors.
