The Mirror In The Roadway: A Study of the Modern Novel by Frank O’Connor. Knopf. $4.50.
What claim has a poet or writer of fiction to be listened to when he turns his hand to criticism? Despite a rather superstitious tradition of respect for his views the answer is obviously contingent on the criticism he proffers. Coleridge’s was engrossing, Stephen Spender’s and V. S. Pritchett’s isn’t. No doubt a critic without original literary experience of his own is at a disadvantage, working with his left hand only, but that experience will not by itself guarantee his criticism. The greatest dramatist to use our language was also an actor, but this doesn’t mean that Frank Vosper and Emlyn Pilliams are great dramatists.
