The Sot-Weed Factor by John Barth. Doubleday and Company, $7.50.
If the Review were a learned journal, and if your reviewer were a scholar, The Sot-Weed Factor would occasion a field day among sources and analogues. We might indicate some of its literary origins and effects by saying that it was begotten by Don Quixote upon Fanny Hill; or perhaps with equal justice that it is by Rabelais out of Moll Flanders. Completeness would require us to say that our author had been soused in Sterne and pickled in Fielding; that we suspect him of knowing Candide pretty well and of having a commendable love of Chaucer. Of actual sources employed by our author, we should say nothing, knowing nothing. But we would refer joyfully to his brilliantly impudent manufacture of sources, such as the heretofore lost journals of Lord Henry Burlingame and of Captain Jn° Smith, which considerably revise the familiar story of Pocahontas. We might have to wonder whether it was indeed a practice of the late seventeenth century to send boatloads of whores to the Colonies, but granted that they did, we are not surprised to learn what happened when one of those vessels was boarded by pirates. It is of course mandatory, in writing about literary London of this period, to discuss coffeehouses, and our review would have to say that Addison apparently did not tell us the whole truth about them.
