The Complete White Oxen: Collected Short Fiction of Kenneth Burke. University of California Press, $6.50.
Modern literature began with a bang in 1912; then two years later the whole modern age followed. The republication of these stories is an act of piety toward a past generation; not, indeed, the generation that created modernism but the one following, which consolidated its gains. This latter generation, though it had some notable creators, is perhaps better characterized by its group of “creative” critics. Kenneth Burke was one of a band including Empson, Ransom, Blackmur, and several other critics more innovative than magisterial, who explored the inroads that the “men of 1914” made into literature’s complacencies. One mark of this group was that they wrote criticism as a kind of poetry, and vice versa. They all knew what Pound meant when he wrote in 1934 that “the criticism of Seneca in Mr. Eliot’s Agon is infinitely more alive, more vigorous than in his essay on Seneca”; they all felt avant la lettre the force of Malraux’s notion that the appropriate response to a work of art is another work of art, even if it go under the guise of criticism. Hence it is stil possible to read large chunks of, say, Seven Types of Ambiguity (even though “ambiguity” itself has been oversold) with the pleasures proper to “the dance of the intellect among words”—Pound’s definition of logopoeia, the ironic and critical mode of poetry.
