Inventory: Essays by Michel Butor edited by Richard Howard. Simon and Schuster, $7.95.
In one of the pieces collected in Inventory Michel Butor remarks of Jackson Pollock that we haven’t caught the fierce cry of the last canvases, and deplores our refusal to hear, our indifference to the figure of the painter “screaming to you that he is lost, that you are lost too. …” And he goes on to say of paintings—and what he says here holds good for the general attitude that informs his dealings with art and literature—that “we are interested only when something in the concept of a composition tells us about nature and ourselves, speaks to us of the world and its workings.” Butor is lumped together with Robbe-Grillet as a New Novelist, but it is clear that he is closer to being an Old Humanist. It is necessary merely to add a simple proviso to let the figure stand, that Old Humanists are marked these days by an awareness of the problematic affair that the process of creation has become. We can think of them as literally twice-born: the humanism leads in Butor to the studies in cultural history, the sense of the problematic to the obsessive interrogation of the means of art. In France the double legacy produces a criticism preoccupied with the physics and metaphysics of art, that in a post-Marxist way seeks to get at the underlying conceptions of order—in its latest metamorphosis, “ideology”—that make works of art possible, formally as well as historically possible. In the case of Butor, it leads to a preoccupation with the relationship between the inventions of art and the historical world we live in, and to a conception of the novel as “laboratory”—a conception grim enough to suit the anxieties of the day.
