The Rise and Fall of English: Reconstructing English as a Discipline by Robert Scholes. New Haven: Yale UP, 1998. 203 pages. $20.00, hardbound.
What is literature? What is its value? Why is it written? Why is it read? This list of questions and a host of other concerns that this series implies may seem like a latter-day academic equivalent of “How many angels can dance on the head of a pin?” This series may appear to consist of questions impossible to answer and irrelevant or at least tangential even if answered accurately. Yet even scholastic questions about dancing angels have a kind of staying power. And the same can readily be said for questions concerning the status of literary works of art, their producers, and their consumers. Trying to assign a value to things literary has proven difficult, since we seem hard-pressed to assign value generally. Yet even if Barbara Herrnstein Smith is correct about the contingency of value relative to a literary work of art, plenty of counter-examples can be found, where attempts are made to advance the value of literature as “less” contingent and “more” necessary, responding to a felt need to account for the enduring attraction and power of literature. Not surprisingly, the focus of these renewed efforts falls frequently on “the story of English” set within the context of colleges and universities.
