The modern English department is notoriously easy to attack; and it is most obviously exposed to attack by the stupid, or trifling, or plainly muddle-headed books, articles, dissertations, and theses which its machinery commits it to turn out. Even random quotation from these exhibits allows one to make out a case against it. This is not the attack which I propose to make here—not that I disparage it. I think that it is healthful to remind ourselves constantly of the amount of rubbish which we produce. But there is a measure of justice in the obvious reply, that no system is to be condemned by the incidental stupidities of some of its proponents. A certain amount of waste, a certain amount of folly, may be the necessary concomitant of the practical functioning of any plan of English studies. Be that as it may; I am anxious to get at the system itself—and at its best, not only as a matter of fairness but of strategy.
I suppose that it would be generally agreed that the late Professor Edwin Greenlaw was one of the ablest scholars that the system has produced, and that his Province of Literary History stands as one of the most intelligent defenses of the aims pursued by our best departments. In that work, Greenlaw undertakes to assess the rival claims of the critics and the literary historians. The following passage is typical of his position:
