Read the winning piece of our 2025 Nonfiction Contest “Through the Mirror” by Jessie Cato selected by Lucy Ives.

Read

Autumn 1940 • Vol. II No. 4 • Literature and the Professors: A Symposium |

Scholars as Critics

The basic function of the literary scholar was clearly indicated by Dr. Johnson when he remarked that “all works which describe manners require notes in sixty or seventy years” if they are to be understood. The significance of a remark of this kind depends almost entirely on the conception of understanding which lies behind it. For Dr. Johnson undestanding was a serious and adult act involving the whole man, an act of evaluation and judgment. “The truth is,” he said, “that the knowledge of external nature, and the sciences which that knowledge requires or includes, are not the great or frequent business of the human mind. Whether we provide for action or conversation, whether we wish to be useful or pleasing, the first requisite is the religious and moral knowledge of right and wrong . . . . Prudence and justice are virtues and excellencies of all times and of all places; we are perpetually moralists, but we are geometricians only by chance.”

It is largely this involvement of the whole man which has given Dr. Johnson his reputation for a kind of perverse critical blindness. For him a work of art was a serious representation of the human world; it had to be true. It is far more important, for example, that he sought thus earnestly to evaluate the world of Milton’s poetry than that the judgment which resulted was, as we believe, wrong. For Dr. Johnson did judge Milton’s poetry, and the quality of his critical seriousness is in that judgment to give it value however it may seem, from our different point of view, in part mistaken. That value could not exist without the learning which gives it body; but only when learning is alive with critical seriousness does it have anything but an antiquarian interest.

Already have an account? Log in

Join KR for even more to read.

Sign up for a free account and read any five pieces a month.
Sign Up and Read for Free



Or become a subscriber today and get complete, immediate access to our digital archives at every subscription level.
Literary critic, Arthur Mizener (1907-1988) was Mellon Foundation Professor of English at Cornell University from 1951 to 1975. In addition to other works, he authored the first biography of F. Scott Fitzgerald, The Far Side of Paradise (1951) along with a biography of Ford Madox Ford, The Saddest Story: A Biography of Ford Madox Ford (1971).

Read More

Subscribe

Your free registration with The Kenyon Review includes access to exclusive content, early access to program registration, and more.

Donate

With your support, we’ll continue 
to cultivate talent and publish extraordinary literature from diverse voices around the world.