In the Irish literary movement the two leading protagonists, Joyce and Yeats, play complicated roles. Yeats acts the part of founder but, as the movement progresses, seems to be thinking of something else. Joyce acts first the rebel and then the perverse disciple of the movement. It is the gregarious Yeats who organizes the literary societies but whose poetry, even when it uses Irish themes, suggests a proud, lonely world aloof from Dublin, and Joyce who exiles and isolates himself only to make his subject Dublin and more Dublin. Their family backgrounds and social positions had something to do with their literary directions: Joyce belonged to the Catholic majority that constitutes ninety per cent of the population of southern Ireland, and he anchored his work in common life; Yeats, on the other hand, a member of the Anglo-Irish Protestant gentry, came naturally upon a more detached point of view, and tried to impress a disinterested nobility upon his country and to root his writings in uncommon experience. The relationship of the two men ended in mutual respect, but at first was, especially on Joyce’s part, turbulent and uneasy.
Joyce could hardly have avoided Yeats’s work even if he had wanted to. By the late ‘nineties, when Joyce was a student at University College, Yeats was the acknowledged leader of what was already being called a literary renaissance. But he was beginning to run into difficulties, for his form of nationalism was too careless of immediate aims to satisfy the chauvinists, and his religious principles were beginning to alarm some of his literary supporters. He had, it is true, anticipated the religious issue, and given disinterested encouragement to both Catholic and Protestant writers in the various literary societies; with a symbolist’s impartiality, he even used occasional Catholic images in his writings. But a careful reader could not help noticing that the dominant impulse of his work was pagan, and that Christianity in any form appeared only when its symbols would fit in with older pagan ones. Yeats seemed to find the angels less interesting than the fairies, and to prefer the Celtic gods to more conventional deities. Ancient druids usually came off better in his stories than modern priests. Sometimes he went further still. In two of his stories, The Tables of the Law and The Adoration of the Magi, he intimated that a new god, perhaps even the Antichrist, was on his way to replace the current divinity. While these notions were common enough among comparative mythologists and occultists, Catholic Dublin was not accustomed to entertaining them. Yeats’s publisher was so worried over the reception of the two stories that he insisted upon issuing them separately and gave no indication on the title page of who had published them.
