Part of the pleasure of seeing Mr. Trilling’s essays1 brought together surely consists in finding what he has been up to all along. As they came out in periodicals, or as one heard them from platforms, it always seemed that their author wrote from a solid, though developing, point of view, from some vantage, not precisely that of the audience, but which the audience was under the natural expectation to share, like the weather, or even like the momentum of society. The words seemed to have a source and a purpose, an origin and a destination. It was rather like Reinhold Niebuhr’s iteration that in Christianity, and in Christianity alone, history is meaningful―but the meaning is not yet. Now reading the essays all together, although we see that the meaning is still not revealed, we see better by what means, and against what difficulties, the author goes about the business of cultivating his long hope.
We see that he cultivates a mind never entirely his own, a mind always deliberately to some extent what he understands to be the mind of society, and also a mind always deliberately to some extent the mind of the old European society taken as corrective and as prophecy. He is always aware, to use one of his phrases, of the cost of civilization. He knows the price of glory and the price of equity; that the price of one may be the expense of the other; that the two are incompatible; and that both prices must be paid. He knows; or at any rate he knows that he does not know. I suppose that if he accepted this language at all, he would allow that this knowledge represents the Human price; and he might go on that this is why he has cut down on tykish impulses and wild insights, why he insists on using a mind never entirely his own.
