In a recent interview the novelist Edmund White said that a turning point for him came when, as he was writing States of Desire, he stopped pitching the book to an imaginary straight reader—stopped explaining gay cultural references, stopped worrying if what he was saying put gay experience in an unattractive light. I wonder if there’s a correspondence between White’s turning point and the consensus that has emerged during the past decade that the writer’s former ideal of becoming “universal,” a mouthpiece for the whole culture, is unrealistic. We can understand why Elizabeth Bishop, in the ’70s, might refuse to have her poems put in an anthology of women poets (let alone one of lesbian poets) for fear of being pigeonholed as a writer of minority interest only. But it’s hard to imagine anyone making a refusal like that today. When I read writings by women, by people descended from races other than European, or by straight people, of course I discover overlaps with my own experience, but the differences interest me just as much as the similarities. I don’t go to literature either to find a facsimile of myself, or in search of some “universal” that purports to be the final essence of humanity. Even within my “category” there are plenty of differences: I certainly haven’t understood everything there is to understand about the pluralistic experience of gay men living in America now.
To see what would come of it, I undertook an essay review of writings from several genres by gay men. The novel struck me as the place to start because one of the publishing categories most discussed this past year was “the New Gay Fiction.” It’s reassuring to know that contemporary trade-book publishing counts several editors “out” as gay, and that there is an organization called the “Publishing Triangle” concerned to improve the situation of gay writing. It’s also good to see that the Men on Men anthology of short fiction is now established as a regular series. Even so, considering the mass of gay men’s writing currently published, maybe it’s time to pay the New Gay Fiction the compliment of moving beyond self-congratulation. Without “autocritique” no movement is going to stay in peak condition.
