Rainer Maria Rilke by E. M. Butler. Macmillan. $5.00
Miss Butler’s book has the distinction of being the first full-length study to appear in any language (or at least in English) of the life and works of Rainer Maria Rilke, whose poetry is now available to some degree in most of the tongues of the western world. This gives it a certain significance, which it is, unfortunately, far from deserving; for it is also one of the most unaccountably ill-tempered and prejudiced estimates ever to be written of a major figure. In the suspicious scrutiny it brings to bear on the poet’s character it reminds one of Esther Shephard’s study, Walt Whitman’s Pose, which at least had the honesty to confess itself a piece of literary detective work. The invective and floundering confusions of the critical passages, however, recall nothing so much as a petulant bluestockinged Canute belaboring the element that baffles him.
