He who seeks to define Romanticism is entering a hazardous occupation which has claimed many victims. It would be foolhardy to desire to multiply the difficulties. I wish to state at the outset, therefore, that I am not concerned with that Romanticism which is taken for the eternal opposite to the principle of Classicism. The thesis that literary expression oscillates between the two contradictory limits of Romanticism and Classicism, in much the same way as the human society or the conduct of the individual may be presumed to oscillate between the two opposite poles of Good and Evil, is an intriguing point of view that will have to be left to another occasion. For the present, I am content with the more limited problem of defining the Romanticism of what is generally called the Romantic Period in European Literature, that century which may be roughly described as stretching for fifty years on either side of the year 1800.
Certainly a comprehensive definition of this Romanticism, with some sharpness to it, is desirable. For in the past our comprehensive definitions have not been sharp, and our sharp ones have been provincial. The general definition generally agreed upon is that Romanticism comprises the myriad escapes from Neoclassicism. Unless Romantic literature is much less significant than has been habitually assumed, such a negative statement only conceals the bankruptcy of the effort. The sharp definitions, on the other hand, by appearing to contradict one another, prove their inadequacy. Brunetière, for instance, called Romanticism the discovery of the ego. Others have said that it was the discovery of nature; still others, the return to medievalism. Watts-Dunton believed it the rediscovery of wonder, and an American clergyman-critic of the transcendental period praised it as the literature of aspiration. More recently, Professor Babbitt has been disgusted by its approval of the irrational; Mario Praz accuses it of having been the hot-bed of decadence; whereas critics of sociological interest deplore its stimulus to escape from reality. We need not become alarmed if differences in critical standards lurk among these variations of descriptive effort. The descriptions are all correct when applied to individual authors. Byron and Hugo are clearly egoistic. Chateaubriand and Wordsworth are absorbed by description of the scenery. Scott in England and Tieck in Germany represent a medieval revival. But there is aspiration, the hope for a better world, in Shelley and in Hugo also, while in the later work of Chateaubriand and Shelley many persons have found an escape from reality into a world beyond our time and space.
