For Whom The Bell Tolls by Ernest Hemingway. Scribner. $2.75
What was for long the sign of Ernest Hemingway’s work—the curious tension between subject matter and style, between the themes of violence and the perfectly controlled prose—has gone. Hemingway was extraordinary among modern prose writers for exactly this reason, that he pressed his style into the service of his subject matter in a rather special way: the style was the immediate representation of the moral attitude of the author toward his material, it objectified the author’s values and thus in itself was comment in writing otherwise unhampered by comment. When, however, the subject matter began to change—from violent experience itself to the expressed evaluation of violence—the manner began to change. The separation seems to take place in the story, “The Snows of Kilimanjara,” but it is in the novel To Have and Have Not, that the fumbling transition is clearest. The first third of this book is superb narrative in the old manner; but as Hemingway lets himself into the theme proper thereafter, the book begins to break down, and the end is a debacle, the noisy collapse of a style and technique simply unable to support their matter. Before, the style in itself was moral comment; with a change in moral attitude, that style was necessarily disrupted. In For Whom the Bell Tolls we may witness a new style, less brilliant but more flexible, as it integrates itself. That is a very exciting literary spectacle.
