It is a commonplace that music allows far more repetition than any other art, with the possible exception of architecture. In the general inadequacy of musical aesthetics, however, practically no attention has been given to the various roles played by this fundamental device or to the highly diverse effects which it produces. It is easy to distinguish at least three general types of musical repetition which have boundaries as clear as those generally established by aesthetic categories, and these three may be conveniently described as formal, intellectual, and literary. Formal repetition is like the reiteration of the last line of a ballade, or the refrain of a song: it is assumed for certain types of musical structures, such as the rondo, and the composer who undertakes to write in these forms implicitly accepts the preconceived pattern. Intellectual repetition is “sameness with difference”; the pleasure which comes from the theme and variations, for example, is largely the result of following the changes made in a pattern which contrives to give highly different effects while remaining basically the same. Literary repetition is called for by considerations lying outside the music itself, and is thus confined to works of programme music, in which the reappearance of a person, situation, or idea calls for a repetition of the musical theme which has been chosen to represent it. The Wagnerian leitmotif is perhaps the most familiar example of this type: whenever Siegfried appears, or is even mentioned in an important connection, the appearance of his horn-motif somewhere in the orchestra is obligatory.
It is my purpose here, however, to discuss a type which may belong to any of these categories, but occurs less commonly in the second. This fact implies correctly that it is a variety of repetition which makes little appeal to the intellect. It is, in fact, a type which is easily recognized by its emotional effect, and which, for lack of a better name, I shall call “triumphant repetition.” Any musician must have observed that there are certain compositions in which even a formal and expected repetition produces a tremendous emotional response. An investigation of this response and the causes which combine to produce it will be interesting in itself, and may even throw a little light on other problems in musical aesthetics. Three striking examples of triumphant repetition will serve amply to illustrate its characteristics, and the more familiar these examples are, the simpler an analysis will be. Hence I have chosen the final appearance of the subject in Bach’s “Little” G minor Fugue (since organ registration is highly variable with different instruments and performers, we may as well consider Stokowski’s conducting of his own transcription for orchestra), the last appearance of the principal melodic subject in the Finale of Beethoven’s Eroica, and the reappearance of the introductory theme of the first movement of Tschaikowsky’s Fourth Symphony in the coda of the last movement.
