Most of us will acknowledge wisdom only when her children have justified her. Recently in the pages of the Kenyon Review Mr. R. P. Blackmur in a review of Mr. Mortimer Adler’s How to Read a Book made some suggestions towards examining Mr. Adler’s method by its results in dealing with imaginative literature. The procedure should be extended: of Mr. Adler’s two recent books1 we can scarcely avoid taking one as expressive of the method of his reading, the other as one fruit of that method. Going further, we ought not to tear Mr. Adler out of his context, and, if we are to consider him at all, we ought to consider him in connection with the educational crusade which he has been most energetic in publicizing: the educational program at St. John’s College in Annapolis, Maryland. My judgment is that Mr. Adler is less important as a philosopher than as a publicist, and that the St. John’s program, whatever success it may finally have, will prove in the long run more important than any of Mr. Adler’s writings for the state of American intelligence. Certainly, one would be hard put to attach much importance to a work like his How to Read a Book except in connection with the St. John’s program, and the possibility of reform that this program holds up to American education.
No plan for liberal education can be broached in the United States without immediately raising an issue of liberalism—either its liberalism or liberalism in general—, and whether or not this is the proper salute to the propounders, we expect them to make at least some effort to lay the clamor. Where conflicts rage at too great cross-purposes, one suspects either there is no issue or something is wrong with the words people are using. My own opinion of the St. John’s program, that it suffers from an excess of liberalism, may seem to give some support to the suspicion that at least the latter is the case, since this opinion runs directly counter to the one apparently everywhere current, that the error of St. John’s is an excess of dogmatism, and I would hesitate to advance it were I not also conscious that the professionals living off our educational system are likely to brand as “dogmatic” any program that does not include orientation courses. I am aware too that the publicists for St. John’s have made a great deal of the fact that St. John’s is a revolt against the elective system and a return to discipline, but I can also perceive that the dogmatic tone of Mr. Hutchins’s Higher Learning in America may have been sustained only by its brevity and its consequent summary character, and by the fact that the evils Mr. Hutchins attacked were, and are, so definite and glaring. Of course, no words are more bandied about, with proportionate loss of meaning, than “dogmatism” and “liberalism.” To qualify the criticism: the danger in the St. John’s program I am concerned with is the danger of one of its emphases, the emphasis on reading so and so many books, the “hundred best books” emphasis, which can degenerate into merely a new tone rung on the old formula of “the best that has been thought and said.” Such emphasis seems to be placed on the technique of interpretation (as if this technique could be communicated without a content), that St. John’s, which is popularly supposed to have an axe to grind, may come to the point of having nothing to teach but a method, if in fact this method does really exist, thus returning, by its own particular circle, to the errors it set out to combat. What is the end which the leaders at St. John’s define for education? A statement so general in its lack of definition, so smug in its appeal to the sentiments of self-satisfaction in our nation, as the statement of Mr. Adler and the St. John’s catalogue, that they profess to educate young men for democracy by training them in the liberal arts, I cannot imagine striking fire from the mind of anyone hopefully waiting for a concrete word to be said. Which aspect of our American democracy does the blurb intend? We are educating for American democracy if we educate people to accept Street and Smith, the average output of the moving-picture industry, a city-park to walk in, as an adequate human environment. To educate for democracy would seem to mean educating students to accept the editorials in the New York Times at their face value. There is only one end which a follower of the philosophy of St. Thomas Aquinas—the role Mr. Adler seems to have assumed in American philosophy—should be able to understand, and that is education for God. Given the context of our bourgeois democracy, with its various human degradations at the moment apparently everywhere forgotten for the more grim-looking evils of fascism, it might seem the last thing a penetrating and honest Thomist could say, that we should educate for democracy. The only hope for St. John’s is that at this point its leaders are simply singing a siren song for the support of the bourgeois paterfamilias and do have some more positive conviction that they are willing to show. If there are any positive convictions behind St. John’s, we would like to know which of the many philosophies the student who is being taught them is supposed to believe? Are these all represented as equally plausible? No one can come to understand a philosophy without accepting or rejecting it, or making an effort to accept or reject it, whether in whole or part, and the prospect of a St. John’s graduate, able to answer an examination on any philosophy, but believing none, strikes me with a more dismal chill than that of the dreariest nursling of progressive education whose only idea of philosophy might be that it is a strange mythology of the past, somehow superseded by machines and industry.
