Few if any critics live who write better criticism than Mr. R. P. Blackmur; I mean subtler and deeper criticism, and sounder. He probes the poem with a keen instrument, and his judgments, so far as such an adjective is ever applicable, are close enough to infallible.
He is decidedly what we should now be calling a “new critic.” The like of his latest book1 could hardly have appeared in any period earlier than the last two decades. There are violent disagreements among the new critics, but any one of these critics shows the influence of the others, and the total effort amounts to a sort of collaboration. The new criticism in this respect is in somewhat the same situation as the new physics, or the new logic. It may be destined presently to arrive at something proportionately as definitive, and, by comparison with the shapeless miscellany of all prior criticism, as radically new, and fertile. Mr. Blackmur has plenty of characteristic, insights of his own, yet everywhere he reveals an eclecticism which is real, though it does not refer backward beyond the new and still living critics. Intentionally or otherwise, he is a collaborator with such other critics as Richards and Empson, Eliot, Tate, Winters, and Brooks. I quote one sentence in evidence:
