D.H. Lawrence took his ideas quite seriously. He did not think of himself as an “artist” in the usual sense of this word. He had no use for men who spent their lives expressing themselves for the sheer sake of expression. His dominating interest was in the moral assimilation of experience, or rather, since it was not passive but aggressive, in the molding of objective conditions to fit his personal needs. Often the poet in him catches a glimpse of nature and records its quivering radiance, or responds to the teeming earth, to the movement of light, to the electric energy of living things. But the response is by the way, as he hurries to a sermon or to a biopsy which will reveal the extent of the malignancy which ails modern life. Why then has criticism concerned itself almost exclusively with the problem of Lawrence rather than with Lawrence’s problems? Are his ideas so childish that they are beyond notice? We seem to read him only in order to psychoanalyse him. Our neglect is unintelligible since we can not very well deny that there must be some connection between the place we accord a man in literature and his ideas, or if you prefer, his attitudes. And the more puzzling if we remember that while we show no serious interest in his philosophy we feel—and certainly with adequate justification—that Lawrence encouraged the development of forces which are essentially inimical to an enlightened conception of the good life.
In this essay—and the word is intended in its literal meaning, for it is no more than a trial—I propose to analyse some of the most important of Lawrence’s ideas in order to show that they refer to one central concern: the need to find a means of living intensely in a world which makes the realization of this aim impossible. This is to say that Lawrence was fundamentally concerned with one of the central problems of our day, the meaning of life for modern man. Those who can no longer get their orientation from the traditional values of our culture—from religion, from patriotism, or from the satisfaction of the will to acquisitiveness or to dominion—still have a few alternatives besides a cynical surrender to futility. One of these is the search for meaning through creative activity; but Lawrence, who did find meaning in this way, never considered it seriously as a possibility, and turned art, quite consciously, into an instrument of moral reform. Another is the search for meaning through political action; but Lawrence was too deeply divided in his class allegiance and too confused about his political attitude to make use of this way. Still another is the search for meaning through pure experience; and this is the way which would appeal to an individualist like him.
