When my neighbors complained
the roots of our cypress were buckling
their lot, the landlord cut the tree down.
I didn’t know a living thing three stories high
could be so silent, until it was gone.
— Rick Barot, “On Gardens” (5-6,1. 26-30)
In his first Surrealist Manifesto of 1924, the poet André Breton trumpets his singular criterion of beauty as if it were a challenge. Thus he embodies something of the rebellious vitality implicit in the beautiful itself, something less indicative of formal harmony or bourgeois complacency than the revolutionary summons of the strange. “Let us not mince words,” he states, “the marvelous is always beautiful, anything marvelous is beautiful, in fact only the marvelous is beautiful” (14). Pitched to provoke, the statement relies upon a polemical sureness of phrase and purpose that would both liberate and dictate the terms of liberation—a paradox that has come to haunt our memory of the man himself. That said, the rhetoric of secular zealotry contains within it a highly mercurial and revisionary distinction in danger of being obscured by the force of Breton’s certitude. Beauty in its alliance with marvel figures as the threshold of the uncertain, a realm without pre-determined and thus familiar formal character. Breton needs no logical argument, since, when it comes to beauty, no such argument exists. Rather he summons us to look more closely at the biases implicit in the language of aesthetics, to put extreme pressure on the words “marvelous” and “beautiful” in ways that beg a reconsideration of just what these categories mean as embedded in one another, and how the notion of “marvel” brings to “beauty” a sense of dissonant engagement, both psychological and epistemological.
